So what is the Extreme Fat Smash Diet anyway?
Here I am going into my fifth week on the Extreme Fat Smash Diet and I haven't explained what it's about. If you don't have the book, go over to Suite 101 to read Tracy Rose's review of Dr. Ian Smith's book Extreme Fat Smash Diet - Extreme Fat Smash Diet - Lose Weight Fast with Dr. Ian Smith.
Here's an overview, but you really need to read Extreme Fat Smash Diet to get all the details. (If you're a fast reader like me, it should only take you a few hours to read it.)
The basic principles to the Extreme Fat Smash Diet
- It's for people who want to lose up to 18 lbs. in as little as six weeks in a healthy way. This is what originally attracted me to the diet - fast and healthy. However, while it's been very healthy, it hasn't been very fast in my case.
- Portion control - pretty obvious.
- Smart eating choices - eating low or not fat versions of favorite foods, high fiber foods, and low Glycemic Index (GI) foods. This is the first time I've done low GI and thought it was a big advantage over Weight Watchers.
- Five small meals plus two snacks per day and eating every three hours - again portion control and reducing cravings by eating frequently. I've been very challenged to plan well enough to eat every three hours, however. Sometimes I'm not that hungry and often I'm too busy to eat.
- Exercise - not my favorite thing, so being "forced" to exercise was a big incentive.
- Getting your metabolism going by exercising, eating every few hours, increasing muscle mass, keeping hydrated, reducing stress with meditation/yoga, eating protein-rich foods, and getting a good night's sleep - all good stuff.
- You can booze it up...a little. In Cycle 1, you're allowed two 6-oz glasses of wine for the entire week. In Cycle 2, you may have two 6-oz glasses of wine, and two 12-oz bottles or cans of beer for the entire week. In Cycle 3, you're allowed two 6-oz glasses of wine, two 12-oz bottles or cans of beer, and 1 mixed drink for the entire week. You can't believe how much I look forward to having my wine.
So how does it work?
There are three cycles in the Extreme Fat Smash diet. Each cycle equals a week and three cycles is one ratation. At the end of a rotation, you can switch back to cycle one or two if you want to lose more weight. However, don't expect the same results since you'll have
With each successive rotation expect to lose no more than 80-90 % of the previous rotation’s loss. Once you’ve hit your goal, you go into maintenance and stay there. If you start gaining weight, leave maintenance and cycle back into the diet until you’ve lost the weight again, then return to maintenance.
Dieting types
- Type α (Alpha) Alphas can lose weight with minimal effort - this is my husband and my friend, Merrie.
- Type β (Beta) Betas must work hard and follow the diet perfectly to see results - I think this is me and probably need to start making adjustments.
- Type γ (Gamma) Gammas work hard yet have modest results.
While the book goes into detail about this, you have to incorporate this manually when you sign up on the Celebrity Fit Club website
The benefits of doing the Extreme Fat Smash Diet online
Yes it costs money, but then so does the book. However, online you have access to preplanned menus, which you can tweak depending on eating preferences and what you already have in your pantry. You can also print out recipes, your daily/weekly menu, and grocery lists - very helpful if you don't have your laptop and a wireless connection with you.
Online you can specify what type of exercise you want to do, for how many minutes, and how many days a week. Since this is all online, your diet is adjusted accordingly to how much working out you're doing. You can either do cardio only, weights and cardio or Harvey's boot camp. I've only been doing cardio, plus a yoga and Pilates class.
You also have online support on the community boards from other members as well as a nutritionist and a fitness expert. And you track everything from meals to weight loss online as well.
There are some negatives to the online site, like you can't tell it if you're an alpha, beta or gamma, and entering multiple forms of exercise done on one day is impossible. Otherwise it's pretty good, workarounds given on the community boards, and they're always trying to upgrade the site to include everyone's food choices.




















Hi Anne-Marie,
It sounds like you're really enjoying the "Extreme Fat Smash Diet". I am familiar with eating every 2.5 to 3 hours and eating whole foods (and learning to cook! :) ) by following the Six Week Body Makeover - 6WBMO. I don't look at it as a diet (although some do), because it's truly a lifestyle change if I want to keep the weight off.
One thing I've learned on the 6WBMO is that alcohol brings your metabolism to a halt, so there's no alcohol included in the plan, unless you are cooking with regular wine. You could be releasing your weight quicker without the added alcohol in your diet, but of course you know what works the best for you. ;)
Keep up the great work, I wish you continued success, see you at goal! :)
All the best,
JoLynn
Posted by: JoLynn Braley | July 01, 2007 at 08:32 AM
I didn't know much about this diet, so I found it very interesting. I'm intrigued by all the diets coming out which incorporate the low-glycemic way of eating in some form. Of course, I'm totally sold on South Beach after losing 42 pounds and keeping it off for nearly three years (with a few small lapses and returning to phase one occasionally for a tune-up). But for anyone who doesn't want to follow a strict diet, I think most people would lose weight if they just eliminated some of highest-glycemic foods like white sugar, white flour and potatoes to start with. Like the previous commenter, I'm surprised your diet allows alcohol on the intial phase. South Beach doesn't allow wine until phase two.
The longer I've eaten the low-glycemic way the more I realize I don't really feel deprived; there are so many good foods that I eat all the time. And I am completely convinced that one of the biggest tips for dieting is to pick a diet that works with your own food preferences. I was never much of a sweets eater, so this way of eating is great for me.
Congratulations on your commitment to exercising. I'm just coming out of a kind of exercising slump where I didn't exercise as much as I usually do for a few months, and it feels great to be getting back to it.
Posted by: Kalyn | July 01, 2007 at 09:05 AM
I haven't really exercised since I was in college. The workout I'm doing now is pretty intense, but I'm hanging in there. What I've noticed though is that I'm already beginning to tighten up. After 10 days! I'm amazed. I think exercise is a real key to permanent weight loss.
Posted by: kathyj333 | July 01, 2007 at 01:51 PM
Hey Anne-Marie - I was interested to read about the plan you're following at present, sounds like it's pretty well balanced. Best wishes for that!
Many thanks for the link as well!! :-)
Posted by: Melanie | July 01, 2007 at 08:31 PM
Wow, I would have guessed that the EFSD was more restrictive than the FSD--but you get more food earlier on than we do ;)
Dr. Ian is my hero!
Posted by: Angel | July 15, 2007 at 07:06 PM
I bought the EFSD and am a little confused on the ability to substitute foods within the days. For example for breakfast I cannot just eat a piece of fruit and a yogurt. I am a runner and I never feel full if I eat only that, so instead I switch that out and eat a cup of Kashi cereal with 1/2c of milk instead. Both of these things are allowed in the first cycle, but will I still lose the weight?? What do you think? Other than breakfast I am ok, and if my breakfast is more calories than the assigned one (which it usually is) I just don't have the snacks for the day and instead eat the "Free snacks". Let me know what you think!! Glad the diet is working for you!
Posted by: Jessica | August 16, 2007 at 08:15 AM
I've been on EFS for a week and lost 9 lbs by day 6. I didnt always adhere to the breakfast menu either b/c usually im not hungry in the a.m.
I would eat just the fruit or just the oatmeal. Later in the day I eat an extra snack or whatever part of breakfast I skipped, but I wouldn't recommend it especially to Betas like myself. To make up for it I work out an extra hour to 1hr 30 mins of whats required & I dont drink the coffee/soda/alcohol(sometimes the meat) that is allowed in order to enjoy extra the snack (which is usually a protein bar its b/c solid, takes longer to chew and its protein!). Many blessings to everyone trying to get in shape!!!!
Posted by: RaeCee | October 07, 2007 at 04:00 PM
I'm currently on my 4th day on the diet & I feel good. I have a lot of energy & I never feel hungry @ all. I've lost a total of 4lbs so far. My total goal is to lose an additional 25lbs. We'll see what happens
Posted by: Teya | April 04, 2008 at 12:19 PM